The other day I headed into the store to buy ingredients to make pesto. Basil, garlic and pine nuts. I grabbed all 3 and headed to the register. The cashier looked at me and said, “You know these are $19.99 right?” I looked down at the puny little bag of organic pine nuts. No way am I paying $19.99 for that. “I’ll just go grab the non-organic kind, that’s fine,” I decided. She smiled. “Those are $17.99.”
What is going on here!? Are pine nuts an endangered species? Am I just late to the party? Have pine nuts always been like this?
This is how small the bag was. 6 oz! Anyway, I did a quick mental scan of my cabinets at home. Did I have anything I could sub in for pine nuts? Hmm…what about pumpkin seeds? I had a bag of them already at home. It could work! I said sayonara to the pine nuts (are they made of gold? I don’t get it) and headed home to experiment. Luckily, I was happily surprised at the awesomeness of pumpkin seed pesto! The pumpkin seeds gave the pesto a unique crunch and nutty flavor, which went perfectly when mixed with my mind-blowing tomato sauce.
Super easy to make, too:
- 1 large bunch of basil leaves, washed/dried
- 2 cloves garlic
- 1 handful pumpkin seeds (pepitas)
- A few glugs of extra-virgin olive oil
Chop up the basil finely. Add the garlic and chop chop chop some more.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/29c1e/29c1e8fc629e68660a53637b3f77a395d162af2f" alt="basil garlic"
Next, add your pumpkin seeds and keep on chopping!
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c3004/c300408e8eec0d19d67f1006c50acecee2ee5e15" alt="pumpkin seeds"
Chop until all ingredients are blended pretty finely.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0399b/0399b7f0bfd32d27522d621e0a7dceafd25660ab" alt="chopped pesto"
Transfer the pesto to a bowl and add a few glugs of olive oil. Mix together. Enjoy with your favorite whole grain bread, pasta, vegetables, or whatever your pesto-loving heart desires. Absolute deliciousness, no pine nuts required. :)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b61d0/b61d03657e7a28f5fc0a490d1a31b180c9307e6b" alt="pesto complete"
Judy Griffin says
Looks awesome. You know I use pignoli nuts or walnuts for pesto and tey are much more reasonable.
Natasha Kay says
Great idea! I remember being a grocery store clerk back in high school and pine nuts were always the one bulk item that people would have a heart attack over! :)
trish says
I made this today and it was delicious!!! Thanks for the idea!